Last week, we had the honor of being featured on How They Asked, a website devoted to sharing proposal stories! It’s a fun website and Instagram to go through if you have some time to kill. I never used to be a crier, but now I will cry through a beautiful wedding and proposal! Buckle up for a text heavy post.

On this Wedding Wednesday, I thought it could be fun to share our engagement story, in more detail than I did for How They Asked. Truth be told, I never thought we’d be featured so I didn’t dive into as many details when they asked!
Nick and I have been dating since we were 18, our freshmen year of college. We met while we were both dating other people and quickly became best friends. I wish I could tally the amount of times Nick would announce, in front of other people, “I could never date Phoebe, she’s my best friend. It would be too weird,” and I’d be mortified. I definitely had a crush on him, especially after we were both single.
That “only best friend” thing didn’t last very long. One night in the student center, where we spent A LOT of our time talking over coffee, he gently slipped into conversation that the next girl he was going to date, was me. I remember freezing and giggling, unsure what to think.
He walked me back to my dorm and it was snowing. I looked up at him and thought, “This is it! He’s going to kiss me!” But he didn’t. We shared a long hug, and all those stupid sparks people talk about? Definitely there. To this day, he talks about that moment and how he froze because it seemed too perfect: the snow, our conversation, the giddy feeling we both had after confessing our mutual “like” for each other. He was afraid he’d mess it up! And that is one of my favorite things about him.
Fast forward 6 years, 3 months, and 10 days, we found ourself traveling to Lake Placid, NY. We love the Adirondacks and go to Lake Placid every Memorial Day Weekend to kick off summer. When we went the year before, I thought MAYBE he’d propose. This time around, I was sure there was no proposal on the horizon. I kept telling everyone who asked, “No, we’re not getting engaged in 2018. It’s just not going to happen.”
I was getting pretty impatient. I had a lot of friends who had been with their significant other for way less time, but they were getting engaged and married. I had to keep reminding myself that our lives were different, we had careers that were incredibly important to us and marriage just wasn’t in the cards yet. And I convinced myself really well apparently! I just thought, “Maybe sometime in 2019.”
So it didn’t seem weird to me that Nick kept asking if I really loved Lake Placid, if that was going to be “our place” for the rest of our lives—somewhere we’d bring kids, buy a vacation home, visit often. Nick is a planner and he LOVES details. Plus I had a lot going on work wise and in being a part of my friend Grace’s wedding.
So when we went away, I decided to get my nails done. Nick thought that was a great idea, because I never treat myself to manicures. I almost didn’t do it, because it seemed silly to spend the money, but he insisted I treat myself. If I didn’t, he would pay for it! Again, not weird, because he offers stuff like this all time. In the end, I thought he was right: I deserved a $40 manicure, cause I never do stuff like that.

We were renting a cabin and I was super excited to see it plus visit our favorite stores and restaurants. I can be VERY indecisive so I told Nick all I cared about was that we had a balcony or deck with a water view. I was hoping it would be warm enough to swim, but the forecast seemed rainy and chilly. “Oh well,” I said to Nick on the way up. “We can be cozy in the cabin and just relax!” But he was dead set on hiking. He was so worked up about it and I didn’t understand. But like I said, he’s a planner and this had been planned into the weekend.
Friday was super chill and mellow. We stopped in Lake George for brunch, walked around and explored some of the shops there. Then we drove further north to Lake Placid. Our cabin was so cute and and perfect (if you ever go, ask me for the Airbnb reservation—we LOVE the host and have stayed at some of his other properties since!) but it was starting to rain as we headed out for dinner.

It was a full downpour as we walked to town, but miraculously cleared up and we were able to enjoy our meal outside. We walked Main Street and popped into the shops that hadn’t closed yet. And then we paused for a photo in front of Mirror Lake. I captioned it, “Adulthood isn’t always fun, but growing up with you sure is,” because that’s how I felt! Little did I know in less than 12 hours that would be even more true.

We woke up Saturday morning and it was slightly gloomy. Nick got dressed into his “new hiking clothes” that he was insistent on buying. If you’ve seen our proposal photos, you know he wore pants and a colored shirt. All “hiking efficient” and sweat proof, but I wore an old pair of sneakers, yoga leggings, and a workout top. I looked at him and said, “Howdy Ho, Ranger Joe” because he looked like a park ranger! He laughed and we were on our way.
There is such beauty in the 46 Peaks that make up the Adirondacks. We chose to hike Mount Jo, which is one the easier peaks with the best views. We didn’t know if the weather would hold, so didn’t want to find ourselves stranded mid mountain in a rainstorm.
We met a few people on the trail, but mostly we were alone. We decided to to the “shorter, more difficult” trail up and the longer, easier trail down. As we began, the sun came out! And it quickly got HOT. I forgot bug spray and was getting eaten alive, so I said we should give up, that it was okay not to go to the summit. Nick was so angry at me for suggesting that! That we weren’t quitters and the summit wasn’t much further. He was behind me and I said, “Why do you care? It’s not like you are going to propose at the top” as a JOKE. He’s a better actor than I am, because he didn’t betray anything!
We made it to the top and there was a young family there. We talked a bit and then when it was just us, I pulled out my phone to take some pictures. I said, “I wish I brought my little tripod, so we could get a good picture of us!” And Nick said, “I brought mine!” And I immediately loved him for his insane planning of the weekend. He thought of everything!
We posed for a few photos, and then he told me to look out at the view, so he snap that photo. My thought? “He knows I only do this for the instagram photos” and turned around. He snapped a few pictures and then told me to turn around, and when I did, he was there on one knee.

I HAVE NEVER BEEN SO SURPRISED OR SPEECHLESS IN MY LIFE. To this day, I love our story because I always told him I wanted to be completely 100% surprised. And man, did he pull that off.
If you read this far, thank you! I love that I will have this documented somewhere, because it is one of my favorite memories of all time.
